Beware of the Comp Creature

You don't need a haunted house or a fog machine to find real-life horror stories. In workers' comp, the scariest monsters are the ones we create ourselves.

I've seen it happen again and again: a simple injury that should have been wrapped up in weeks suddenly grows claws, fangs, and an appetite for your time, money, and sanity. Sometimes the biggest fright comes from watching a tiny claim mutate into a nightmare.

I call it: The Comp Creature

A Small Scare

This isn't Frankenstein's lab. It's just Tuesday on the warehouse floor. But the first scream is always the same: "Don't worry, it's nothing."

Picture this:

🎃 A warehouse worker twists an ankle stepping off a pallet, scrapes his knee, falls to the floor, and bumps his head.

🎃 He reports it to his supervisor.

🎃 It should be a quick doctor visit, a little rest, maybe light duty, then back to work.

End of story, right? Not if the claim is handled badly.

The Claim Transformation Infection is Spreading and No One Notices.

Trouble begins when the claim is ignored. It doesn't take the employee long to realize that "nothing" is actually "something" that needs a doctor. And here's where the monster starts to grow:

🩸 Delayed reporting. The supervisor waits a week to tell HR.

🩸 HR is unprepared and starts a Google search, "What to do after a work accident"

🩸 No clear medical direction. The worker doesn't know where to go, so he heads to his own doctor.

🩸 Communication breakdown. The supervisor doesn't take it seriously, the employer doesn't check in, the worker feels ignored, and eventually even refuses to talk to the adjuster.

🩸 Distrust sets in. The worker hires an attorney because he's spooked about being left in the dark.

Each step adds another layer of claws, teeth, and glowing red eyes to what could have been a minor sprain or bump on the head.

Now the claim is unrecognizable

What should have cost a few hundred dollars is now a beast chewing through your claim and lurking in your loss runs.

🪦 What was brushed off as a minor incident was actually a bigger medical problem.

🪦 Multiple medical opinions.

🪦 Lawyer involvement.

🪦 Potential time off work dragging into months.

🪦 Costs multiplying like a swarm of gremlins.

How To Slay The Comp Creature

The good news? Monsters like this are preventable.

🔪 Report injuries immediately. No excuses, no waiting.

🔪 Direct medical care (per your State's Requirements). Give your employee the right info and get them to a doctor who understands work injuries.

🔪 Communicate. A quick check-in call can calm fears and prevent misunderstandings.

🔪 Stay consistent. Follow your own process every time - no skipping steps.

Handled right, a claim doesn't need to grow fangs or be scary at all.

The Safe Exit

Halloween is the season for ghosts, goblins, and monsters - but your claims don't need to join them. Keep the real horror in the haunted houses, not in your workers' comp program. Because the scariest thing in workers' comp isn't a haunted attraction... it's letting a tiny claim grown into The Comp Monster. 👣

---

Blog by Chris Cain, CWCP | Podcast Host of Work Comp Chaos

ABOUT CHRIS

Current

• Podcast host of Work Comp Chaos | licensed in multiple states as both an insurance adjuster & agent

• Vice President of The Southern Agency Insurance in charge of Daily Operations, and provides support to clients throughout their claims process

• United Heartland Insurance Company Claims Advisory Council

Speaking Events

• Altaworld Insurance Tech & Innovation Conference: Q&A Discussion: The Role of Automation in Claims Processing - Reducing Fraud or Reducing Jobs?

• Stairbuilders & Manufacturers Association: Hidden Liabilities

• Georgia Public School Board Workers' Compensation Association: How To Handle Work Comp Claims

• Homebuilders of Atlanta: Claims and Warranties

• Lunch & Learn: Various Uses of Life Insurance - Key Man, Tax-Free Benefits, Buy-Sell Agreements

Prior

• State of Tennessee Telehealth Advisory Committee assisting in developing rules and statutes

• Utilization Review Advisory Committee

• Past President of the Tennessee State Claims Association

• Served 15 years as President of the Chattanooga Claims Association